Haley’s video obviously uses Fight Club as a metaphor for a romantic relationship. While this is a rather pessimistic view of romance, the concept is interesting and well done. It captures much of the spirit of the movie but also gives it its own twist.
As usual, I immediately noticed how hot both of the guys — including Haley — are: I can be just as shallow as the next gay man. But I’m also impressed by the visual contrast between the guys’ hotness and the blood and violence of the fight club imagery. This contrast creates an interesting comment about relationships, gay or straight, I think. On the one hand, romance can be beautiful and sexually hot; on the other hand, relationships can be destructive and hurtful to the participants. Something that starts so beautifully can end up being tragically wrong. By the end, the video seems to ask why we do this to each other. Why do we hurt each other so much when we should love one another instead. At least that’s how I read the sadness of Haley’s face in the final part of the video.
Of course the video is also a commentary on the queerness of Fight Club. Weren’t we all expecting Ed Norton and Brad Pitt to make out during it?! This video is what should have happened!
And finally, [spoiler alert] if we think about the intertextuality of this video and Fight Club we might interpret the two fighters differently — not as two people in a relationship but as a metaphor for one person’s internal struggle with his own sexuality (or whatever Ed Norton’s character was struggling with in the movie). If it is about one person and his alter-ego, then we’d have to think more about the tragic tone at the end — this defeat of the “Other” isn’t necessarily a positive one.
Either way, it’s a great video and song.